116: Half a Life (4.22)

Synopsis:  A brilliant scientist (non-crazy kind) kind tries to save his entire planet from destruction, but can’t finish his experiments because his 60th birthday is a comin’.

Memory Alpha Summary:  Forget Obamacare.  This will erase the fucking deficit.

Review:  Why did the Federation make Lwaxana an ambassador?  Up to this point in the series, her social skills have appeared to be severely lacking, irritating most people she meets.  Isn’t that the opposite of what an ambassador should do?

At least she grows a bit in this episode.  I love David Ogden Stiers, and he performs admirably in the role of a scientist who wants to buck his society’s traditions.  The whole idea of ritual suicide to improve dignity and cut health care costs is a bit over the top; but then again, it’s something the Klingons would find honorable.  I wonder, though: if this society has had this rule for centuries, I wonder if their society improved much in the way of medicine.  Presumably, there would then be debates as to raising the suicide age from 60 to say…80 or something.  Also, what if a couple bears a child when they’re say…45?  The kid becomes an orphan while steel a teenager.  Way to go, weird plot device society.

Money Quote

O’Brien, in the middle of another mother/daughter fight:  I’ll go check the pattern buffers.

117: When The Bough Breaks (1.17)

Synopsis:  A mythical, Atlantis like people with amazing powers reveals itself to the Enterprise, then steals its children because they can no longer have children of their own.  They also steal Wesley, presumably because unlike the other children, he’s got sperm.

Memory Alpha Review:  Episode 1.17 is also #117 on the list?  Couldn’t not mention that.

Review:  Remember in Justice when Wesley was going to be executed and Crusher freaked out like most any mother would?  Well, I guess she got over it, because when Wesley is kidnapped here, she only seems moderately concerned.  At least she yells, “Don’t give into fear!” like they teach you in medical school to say.  And Picard does a wonderful job with empathy and keeping a level head throughout the whole ordeal.

Sadly, Wesley is given the perfect episode, having to protect some younger kids and he devises a plan sensible for any teenager, using passive resistance with his captors.  But Wheaton was absolutely not convincing in his role as a leader.

There is also a lot of too transparent technobabble (just like yesterday’s pick, we’re told it’s easier to beam down through a force field than up through it) which kills some of the dramatics at the end.

That said, I do like the plot and I wasn’t really bored.  Plus, I had to giggle at the ending.  Once Dr. Crusher cures everyone from their sickness (and sterility), I realized that Rashella, one of the planet’s few girls of child-bearing age, is going to have to start getting really busy.

118: Realm of Fear (6.02)

Synopsis:  Barclay’s fear of transporters makes everyone else stupid.

Memory Alpha Summary:  Mediocre, atom by atom

Review:   We are told (and not for the first time) that it’s easier to beam people into a sticky spot, but it’s very hard to get them out of it.  Are transporters like tight jeans?  I don’t get it.

While I love watching Barclay, the episode runs a bit long to me.  The special effects are kind of hokey (when they are supposed to be scary), and it seems all of the other super smart officers are intentionally missing the obvious while Barclay is the only one who has a theory as to what’s been happening.  At least we get lots of O’Brien.

119: A Matter of Time (5.09)

Synopsis:  A scientist–whom we know is not a scientist because he’s not one-track mind crazy–comes back in time to “observe” the Enterprise crew in a crisis.

Memory Alpha Summary:  Would be lower on list, but Robin Williams couldn’t play the part

Review:  A rather inane episode for thirty-five minutes or so until Picard and Rasmussen have their one-on-one in the ready room when Picard begs him to let him know what the future holds.  It’s a pretty awesome confrontation.   Then we have the not surprising at all ‘gotcha’ ending when Rasmussen is apprehended.  What bothers me is that the spacecraft from the 26th century disappears, presumably to the past, and nobody seems to care.  Isn’t that a really, really bad thing that was proven by Biff Tannen with the Grace Sports Almanac?

Survivor X, Week 14: Decline

This week, we had to write about a character’s decline.  That’s it.

Dr. Eugene Westphal  sat forward in his chair, elbows on his knees.  He started to speak, paused, and then made sure he was looking the Chief of Staff directly in the eyes.   “So you’re firing me.”

“Of course not,” said Dr. Marcus Jansen, leaning back.  “I was hoping you’d consider taking a spot on the board.”

Dr. Westphal’s left eye twitched, the usual sign he was holding back.  “You know I don’t belong there.   I’m a surgeon, dammit, not a paper pusher.  Besides, those bastards are the reason why we’re sitting here, right?”

Dr. Jansen sighed.  “It’s not just the board.  You’ve been making mistakes, Gene.  The sponge you almost left inside Mrs. Hansen.  The cut on Mr. Cartwright you started in the wrong spot.  The…”

“I’m quite aware of my performance.  If we’re going to sit here and count surgical errors I’m sure I’m still miles ahead of most of my residents.”

“Gene.”  Dr. Jansen sat forward again, clasping his hands on the desk.  “We’ve known each other for almost forty years.  I consider you a friend.  And as your friend, I have to be honest with you.  I think your memory is slipping.  And I don’t mean dementia, Christ no.  But these past few months I’ve…”

“Fuck you, Marcus.  And fuck the board, too. ”  Dr. Westphal rose from his chair and headed towards the door.  “I’ve got a little girl’s life to save.”

Dr. Jansen hung his head, hands still clasped.

********

Clara Carthon was eight years old.  She was bright, eager, and had the jump-rope record at Edgerton Elementary.  She also had a mitral valve that was leaking blood into her lungs.

“Needle driver,” called Dr. Westphal.  The surgery was progressing smoothly.  Clara’s heart had reacted to the bypass machine with ease.  The mechanical replacement tested perfectly.  All that was left were the sutures and her transition off the machine.

“Doctor, her heartbeat is increasing.  Blood pressure dropping.”

“Shit!” He handed the driver back to the nurse.  “There’s massive clotting in the CBP circuit.  Increase Heparin to two-hundred!”

“You sure?” said the nurse.  “All the way up from ten?”

“It was at ten?  What the hell?  No, it should have been one-hundred.”

“So, you…”

“One-hundred!  Now heads-up people.  This could be touch-and-go.”

Though appearing calm to the lay observer, the surgical team worked desperately for an hour and a half.  The clot dissolved and the patient’s vitals slowly returned to normal.  Transition off the bypass machine went without a hitch, and after closure, the patient was transferred to recovery.

Furious at his team, Dr. Westphal washed up in silence.  Ready to lay into the next person who opened their mouth, he glanced at Clara’s chart and noticed the pre-op orders he had written this morning:

HEPARIN:  10 units/mL

His heart sank.

********

The nurse entered Dr. Westphal’s office, appearing guarded.

“I apologize if I was harsh with you in the OR,” he told her.  “It was entirely my fault, the Heparin.  I missed a zero.”

“Doctor Westphal” the nurse choked.  “I’m sorry.  Clara isn’t waking from the anesthesia.  Her vitals are fine.  We think it’s a coma.”

He sat motionless, afraid to breathe.

“I thought you should know before we tell the family.”

“No.”  He couldn’t look at her.  “I’ll tell them.”

It only took a minute to reach Clara Carthon’s family in recovery, but it was the longest walk of Dr. Westphal’s career.  He’d delivered worse news than this, many times.  But this time was different.  As he approached, he could sense the family’s apprehension, as if he were holding a scythe at his side.

“Your daughter’s new valve is working, as is her heart.  Unfortunately, she is not waking as soon as we expected.”

Dr. Westphal could feel his chest tighten.

“We’re afraid she may have slipped into a coma.”

The words hung in the air like a fog, growing more dense the longer no one spoke.  His left eye twitched.

Clara’s father was the first to break the family’s stunned silence.  “What do you mean, coma?  It’s just temporary, right?  She’ll wake up?  How did this happen?”

Dr. Westphal usually offered generalities and platitudes in response to this question.  Today was not usual.

“Your daughter’s blood clotted during the surgery.  While this is always a risk during this type of surgery, it could have been attributed due to an order I…”

“Mr. Carthon?  Mrs. Carthon?” Dr. Xiong interrupted.   “Your daughter is waking up now.  You can see her if you like.  She can’t talk just yet, but she appears to be alert and oriented.”

“Oh thank God!” screamed Mrs. Carthon, hugging Dr. Xiong.

Dr. Westphal watched as Clara’s family hurriedly followed the surgical resident.  He should have felt relief.  He wanted to feel relief.  He felt nothing.

“Dodge a bullet?” he heard behind him.  It was a kid in scrubs.  He didn’t recognize him.

“Here,” said Dr. Westphal, placing his name badge in the intern’s hand.  “Give this to Dr. Jansen.”

“Sir?”

Dr. Westphal walked towards the exit, his head bowed to the floor.  His eye stopped twitching.

Spooky: Using a young girl in this way to tell a story is obviously going to work on me, Mr. Bastard. The story works pretty well period, though, and it feels honestly medical without feeling dull, which is a nice trick to pull off. 3

DK: Straight-forward, but effective. The twitching is a solid recurring touchstone. The clinical language is kind of a double-edged sword; I appreciate the way it heightens the realism, but it also holds me off of getting to know the character as closely, I found. 3

Even though this isn’t the best work I’ve done, it’s certainly the longest I’ve spent writing a story.  The little section about the surgery?  Took me about 2-3 hours of research to make sure I had the details right (as if the judges would even check).  Even then, I’m sure part of it is inaccurate.  All I knew is I wanted a realistic surgery on a child that could put them into a coma if something went wrong.  Didn’t realize that would take me so long to figure out.

As for the rest, I’m pretty happy with it.  The surgical resident stealing the good news (when he’s probably made more mistake than Dr. Westphal if we’re counting) may have been my favorite part. The eye-twitchy thing…threw that in at the last minute.  It doesn’t resonate as much as I would like, but overall I’m happy with it, and my scores.

I’m also happy the Vogons don’t have to vote anybody off.  We’re now down to ten players.  The race is on.

120: Ethics (5.16)

Synopsis:  Worf dies, and we learn very little about ethics.

Memory Alpha Summary:  I mean, Worf lives, and we learn very little about ethics.

Review:  I mean, really.  Crusher is so obviously right here at every turn when it comes to ethical medical practice that it’s not exactly riveting stuff.  Of course, we also have the ethics of Worf’s planned suicide and whether or not Riker should help him, but I imagine there’s probably a Star Fleet regulation against helping fellow crewmates commit suicide, especially while they’re both still commissioned.

That said, I love Riker’s monologue with Worf, and Alexander is not annoying.  It sets the stage for Troi becoming Alex’s godmother and the furthering of Troi and Worf’s relationship.  I’m also impressed with how far they took Worf’s death.  Most time characters die in the teaser, and you know they’re going to come back to life; you’re just not sure how.  Worf death gradually builds, so the first time you might wonder?  But no, he has “backup synaptic functions?”  That’s some pretty sweet-ass evolution if you ask me.

Poker Critique:  Geordi says he peeks through Worf’s infrared transparent cards, but only after the hand is over.  That’s still cheating!  One of the benefits of folding is not allowing your opponent to know what you have so they don’t learn your style of play as easily.

121: Homeward (7.13)

Synopsis:  Worf’s human brother (what?) decides to play God and savior to some humanoids he falls for.

Memory Alpha Summary:  Still not in Kansas anymore

Review:  Season seven was notorious for exploring previously unknown family members of the crew and recycling plot lines from earlier seasons.  In this case, we get Who Watches The Watchers, only worse in every way.  There is virtually nothing new here, other than the solution, which is pretty hackneyed.  I mean, every single villager was asleep at the exact same time when they beamed them to the holodeck?

Meeting Worf’s human brother is neat, but it’s not as satisfying when characters make one-shop stops on the series when there are important emotional ramifications that never get answered later.

At least “The Sign of LaForge” is made me laugh.

122: Night Terrors (4.17)

Synopsis:  Trek’s science lesson about REM sleep.

Memory Alpha Summary:  Not what R. Kelly had in mind

Review:  I love how Picard sends five of his senior staff on the away mission.  Five!

Unbelievably, an entire episode about REM sleep is made somewhat interesting because the science behind it is real and showing how losing REM would affect the crew is kind of fun.  But the episode is nearly all talking and it plods along at an incredibly slow pace.  On top of it, Troi’s flying scenes have to be one of the worst things this series ever produced.  Truly terrifying.

At least Guinan gets to fire a laser gun.  And Data orders Picard to go to bed.

123: Transfigurations (3.25)

Synopsis:  Beverly gets moist for an amnestic patient and tells Wesley all about it.

Memory Alpha Summary:  As Worf says, less talk, more synthehol

Review:  A very slow episode.  Our visitor affects a lot of people on the ship.  Beverly “connects” with him.  He makes Geordi suddenly awesome with women (though only compared to his former clumsy self).  He nearly kills and saves the lives of the crew.  And then he evolves into pure energy.  I guess the episode makes the point how evolution is awesome and governments shouldn’t stop it, but it seems more like a straw man conflict to me.

The bad guys threaten to start firing on the Enterprise if they don’t return the visitor, and then decide to give them two hours to decide.  A lot of enemies of the Enterprise do this.  Why give them time to think about it?  Well, if they didn’t, we wouldn’t have a chance for Picard to give another speech in the conference room, so there’s that.  At least they didn’t say, “two of your Earth hours.”

124: Suddenly Human (4.04)

Synopsis: Picard gets his first try at fatherhood, and further proves that he’s actually better with kids than most of the crew.

Memory Alpha Summary:  AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!

Review:  Despite how uncomfortable he claims to be around kids, when he’s forced (due to Troi’s enormous guilt trip) to try to be a parent he winds up showing more skill than Beverly ever has around Wesley.  And he’s the only member of the crew willing to consider that perhaps this boy would be happier with his adopted parents than his biological grandmother, whom he probably doesn’t remember.  And that’s because the crew shows prejudice towards an alien race they don’t understand.  Huh, shocking.

This is a painful episode to listen to, and not just because the crew is prejudiced and Beverly insists that Wesley try to make friends with every teenage humanoid that walks in the door.  The pain is literal what with all the Talarian screaming that goes on.  While the screaming may be meaningful to understanding the Talarians, it doesn’t make for a pleasant experience for the viewer.