Creator: Carmen Finestra, David McFadzean, Matt Williams
Years: 1991-1999
When I was a teenager I kind of liked Tim Allen, yet I never watched this show much. When it went into syndication I decided to try a few episodes. The first episode I saw was mildly funny. And then I quickly realized every episode was exactly the same. I’m going to borrow a summary of wikipedia:
is very much a cocky, overambitious, accident-prone know-it-all. Witty but flippant, Tim jokes around a lot, even at inappropriate times, much to the dismay of his wife. However, Tim can sometimes be serious when necessary.
That pretty much describes the main character of every terrible sitcom. Granted, that line could also be attributed to Sam Malone. But it isn’t. Because Sam is more interesting than that (and, hey, he’s not married). Tim Taylor is obnoxious, never charming, and barely amusing at times. Al (Richard Karn) provides some decent physical humor on the set of Tool Time. But there’s literally nothing else here. The kids are…kids. The next door neighbor provides the most basic of advice that Tim somehow finds very enlightening.
I remember one joke from the show. Tim is talking about his new hot tub. He mentions the speeds are “Medium, Fast, and Who Needs A Man?” That joke should make nobody laugh who is over the age of fifteen. Granted, that was a pretty racy joke for the 90s. But shock humor dates itself very fast.
I did watch probably seasons 2 through 5 of this. I recall liking it at the time, but it really doesn’t hold up at all. Lots of gimmicks, not many laughs (or at may not many “honest” ones).
I remember there was very little time between me watching this all the time, and realizing it was terrible. It was like a switch flipped and I was depressed about how bad it was. The only one of the kids who could act had left the show and suddenly it was an ultra-predictable stupidfest.