134: Silicon Avatar (5.04)

Synopsis: Riker gets cockblocked by the crystalline entity, while the Enterprise takes on board another mad Federation scientist to combat it.

Memory Alpha Summary:  O Christmas Tree, your leaves slaughter millions

Review: The Federation seriously needs to hold more ethics conferences or something, as their best scientists are the most dangerous.  And prejudiced, as Data gets it again (although this time for being Lore’s brother, not because he’s android).

That aside, it’s a pretty humdrum episode.  Picard statement making the entity’s massacres analogous to a sperm whale devouring cuttlefish is prescient.  Otherwise, there’s little tension and I didn’t find Dr. Marr’s interactions with Data particularly moving.  Also, why is it so easy for non-crew members to take the computer hostage?  Weak writing, I say.

135: Suspicions (6.22)

Synopsis:  Beverly does stupid things because of corona, and not the beer.

Memory Alpha Summary:  In an episode about Beverly, Ogawa gets the memorable quote.

Review:  Man, this episode could have been awesome.  The sixty second teaser is spot on.  We haven’t had a true Beverly episode since Remember Me and I was hoping for a fun mystery.  But it’s executed with the precision of Dr. Zoidberg.

First, we have Beverly doing  a narration for Guinan’s sake for the first half of the episode that just does not work.  It does not feel at all like Beverly is talking to Guinan, but rather home viewers on a bad children’s program.

Second, the ending is insulting as hell, even more so than Aquiel’s ending.  Crusher violates medical ethics and risks causing an incident between the Federation and the Ferengi because she does an autopsy against the family’s wishes when she has no evidence that a murder even took place.  The autopsy isn’t helpful in the slightest.  Naturally, she is facing a hearing.  She then does an unauthorized investigation, risks her life and a perfectly good shuttle craft as well, gets lucky, and solves the case.  Somehow, by episode’s end, she has been absolved of her unethical behavior and is reinstated as ship’s doctor.  What the fuck?  Solving the crime still doesn’t absolve her from desecrating the corpse of the Ferengi in the first place, especially since it wasn’t required to solve the mystery!

Bleck.  And what a waste of Guinan’s final episode.

Survivor X, Week 11: Payoff

When we last met, stories that had cliffhangers were written.  This week, we had to take someone else’s story and provide the ending, while keeping the style as well.  With the holiday week, and the degree of difficulty this challenge had, this one was really tough.  I stayed up late on Friday, spending midnight to 2 am writing mine.  I decided to go with Andy Rustleund’s story.  Here is what he wrote last week:

The Crocville Library was nearly empty this time of year, with the summer sun burning away most students’ interest in books or studying. Earl Toulouse was normally the kind of kid that wouldn’t be caught dead in the library, even during the school year, but the library seemed to be the only place in town with the answers he needed.

Earl had always thought it was a little strange that they never got any new students in class, or that no one ever seemed to move away. Sure, most of the land in the area was a muddy swamp, but there were plenty of nice neighborhoods, a new Super Wal-Mart had just gone up on the edge of town, and the schools were supposed to be the best in the county.

But in history class, no one ever seemed to know exactly when Crocville was founded, or by whom. It wasn’t until the subject came up again later that week with his best friend Martin that Earl really got curious.

“Are you telling me you don’t know anyone who wasn’t born here?” Earl had persisted.

“That’s what I’m telling you, man. I even asked my dad,” huffed Martin on their way to the baseball field. “He said we were Louisiana’s best kept secret or something. Who gives a crap, anyway, man. We gotta get down there before they start without us. I’m not getting stuck in the outfield again.”

As Earl stood in right field, waiting for popups, he decided there had to be some other way to get more information. Tomorrow, he would make up some excuse and get down to the library. There had to be something there.

The town librarian beamed at Earl when she learned that he was interested in Crocville’s history.

“You’re in luck, young man. Mr. Porosus from the Historical Society is here today doing some research himself. Why don’t you two put your heads together and see if you can’t help each other out.”

Earl found Mr. Porosus in the back of the library hunched over a rather large tome, muttering to himself. “Excuse me. Sir…” said Earl tentatively.

Mr. Porosus looked up at Earl slowly. His wispy white hair peeked out from under a checkered hat, and although this part of the library was quite dim, the old man wore dark, gold-rimmed sunglasses on top of an long, pointed nose. His face contorted into a toothy smile.

“Mr. Toulouse. I’ve been expecting you.”

And here’s what I followed it up with:

“You have?” asked Earl, confused. Mr. Porosus beckoned with his hand. Earl walked up, pensive.

“Indeed, son. I hear you’ve been asking questions about our history. I’m always pleased when a young citizen shows interest.”

Earl relaxed a bit. “What are you reading?” His eyes widened as Mr. Porosus stepped aside.

“This,” Mr. Porosus said proudly, “is the entire history of Crocville. Quite fascinating, really. Did you realize our town’s founder was just four years old when he settled here?”

“Wow, really?”

“And that’s not it. It says he promised that nobody in Crocville would ever be lonely or hungry.”

“Cool.” He glossed over the open page detailing Crocville’s first organized baseball team. “What was his name?”

“Bobby Dunbar” said Mr. Porosus. “Now if you’ll excuse me for a minute. Go ahead, take a look-see. I’ll show you more when I return.”

“Yeah, okay” Earl whispered, hopping on the stool. Excited to learn more about Bobby, he flipped the book closed. On the edge of the stool, Earl opened to page one, which was blank. Turning another page, he found the next one blank as well. Then another. And another.

Turning more rapidly, Earl saw only white. Placing his index finger where he felt Mr. Porosus was reading, he skipped ahead several hundred pages. More white. Hands shaking, he flipped back the final pages, reaching the last one. It was not blank. Two words stared up at Earl. His breath caught.

“Like what you found?” said the now ominous voice of Mr. Porosus. He placed a hand on Earl’s neck.

His touch was ice. “What the…” was all Earl could mutter before feeling a swift pain shoot through his spine.

************************

Martin followed Earl to the library, hoping to make fun of his friend, the nerd. From behind the stacks, he watched his friend turning pages frantically. Then, a gangly man came by and appeared to calm Earl down.

Shortly, the man left the library. Martin walked towards his friend.

“Hey Earl!”

“Oh, hi Martin.” Earl yawned. “What’s up?”

“Dude, you looked scared for a minute. The book… is something strange in there?”

“Oh, that? Just some history stuff. Like you said, who gives a crap? See you at practice later?” Not waiting for an answer, Earl walked past Martin and out the library.
Nerd, Martin thought. Before leaving, he walked over to the tome and read two words:

THE END

And now for the judge’s thoughts:

Spooky: Mr. or Mrs. Survivor, you are trying my patience by asking me to like a meta story. However, I have to admit it’s working. Andy set up an excellent eerie tone here, and this story pays it off in a way that’s true to the tone and not in any way obvious. As Earl flipped through the book, I found myself anxious. Well done. 5

DK: Again, not as surprising a direction as some, but I think it pays off that direction really well, and it hits the mark on Porosus’s change effectively. 5

Honestly, I was hoping for 4/4.  Thanks for the compliments gentlemen.  My first ever perfect score couldn’t have come at a better time, as the Vogons suffered their first loss of the season and are now forced to vote somebody out.

As for the story, when I finished I was at 555 words and had to cut it down to 400 to meet game requirements.  Believe it or not, what you read above is virtually the same.  I eliminated a bunch of superfluous words and some flavor text that I wish I could have kept, but I did not have to change any part of the story.

It was a blast to write this.  I immediately knew I wanted Mr. Porosus to be this slick, evil dude who held  the secret of Crocville that needed to be kept.  My mind drifted to the children’s book series about the Tripods and the “capping” process used on teenagers to essentially turn them into non-questioning servants of the aliens.  The part about the book actually being blank except the final page was an addition I made while I was writing.  Martin’s appearance at the end was also something I threw in at the last minute which put me way over the word limit.  But I knew I had to keep it to give the ending a final kick, so I went editing away after that.

By the way, for those who didn’t Google, Bobby Dunbar is a real four-year old boy who went missing in Louisiana some hundred years ago.

136: Emergence (7.23)

Synopsis: Enterprise D: Judgment Day

Memory Alpha Summary:  No ticket!

Review:  It’s been a full season since the holodeck nearly killed members of the crew, so what the hell; let’s bring it back one last time to try and kill off the entire ship.

This episode has a lot of neat imagery, but it feels mostly hollow to me.  The babble about how the Enterprise computer could have become self-aware and created a new lifeform is half-assed, and then nobody seems worried that the computer won’t just do this again someday and jeopardize the crew. The third to last episode of TNG was representative of season seven, recycling old ideas with lazy writing.

137: Man of the People (6.03)

Synopsis:  Troi becomes, according to the producers, “sexy and scary.”  Well, one of them.

Memory Alpha Summary:  Apparently, the writers “gangbanged” the script.  This review had no such treatment.

Review:  Because we didn’t get enough “ambassador who is awesome at negotiations but oh so fragile” in Loud as a Whisper, we now have a guy who dumps his bad emotions on hot chicks and then pretends they’re his mother.  Yeah.

There are some fun scenes in the script, including Troi seducing the terrified ensign and calling another officer a whiny bitch in a counseling session.  But then the episode turns into Unnatural Selection where Troi gets so old she almost dies and then her cells magically return to normal again once things are fixed.

Reduce, reuse, recycle.

138: Manhunt (2.19)

Synopsis: Lwaxana Troi is so horny she falls for a holodeck bartender, Or: Where Tracy Tormé says ‘fuck it’ and combines all of his idea into one plot.

Memory Alpha Summary:  The #1 fact about this episode is that the writer used a pseudonym to protect his name.  That says it all.

Review:  This is one of the weaker scripts for Lwaxana, as she basically acts like a broken record, setting up jokes for the rest of the crew.  Data gets the best scene, as Picard encourages him to tell long, esoteric anecdotes to break up his ‘romantic’ dinner with Lwaxana.  It’s always fun when Picard plays on the holodeck, but in this script it’s just another way to set up more antics for Ms. Troi.

Wesley proves that he’s also racist, showing severe discomfort around the Antedeans because they’re ugly.  At this point I’m convinced all the writers hate Wheaton.

139: Final Mission (4.09)

Synopsis: Wesley’s gone!  Wesley’s gone!

Memory Alpha Summary: Don’t let the door hit you.

Review:  The team who wrote and produced this episode universally loved it (and believe me, they’re not afraid to bash their own work), and for the life of me I don’t understand why.   Almost exactly like Samaritan Snare, there’s a very contrived subplot with Riker at the helm that prevents the crew from helping out Picard and Wesley.  This episode is better, but not by much.  Dirgo’s idiocy is obvious and only there to contrast the level-headedness of our perfect ensign, so when he dies it feels gross.   And while Wheaton does a fine job in his last episode, I am just not feeling this fatherly relationship that Picard is supposed to have towards Wesley.  Finally, the fact that after four seasons they couldn’t give Wesley even a modicum of social skills—not even politeness—is maddening.

Picard’s last quote, to Wesley:  You will be missed.  To borrow a phrase from the year this episode came out…not!

In case you haven’t noticed, this is the first episode from season four on this list.

140: The Schizoid Man (2.06)

Synopsis:  Data gets his circuits raped by yet another maniacal scientist.

Memory Alpha Summary:  But he was asking for it

Review:  How come nearly every scientist in the Federation is a one-track minded crazy person?  Anyway, there’s not much to comment on for this episode.  It could have been really interesting, but the audience knows too much too soon and the crew avoids the obvious problem for too long.  Spiner is great, of course, as he gets to play a less violent, more whorish Lore for twenty minutes.  The best part is probably the final scene, as Riker messes with Data and his short-term memory loss.

141: Up The Long Ladder (2.18)

Synopsis:  Two human cultures (one techy, one Amishy) that separated 300 years ago are brought back together…both wanting some Riker DNA (chica-bow-wow)

Memory Alpha Summary:  Attack of the clones

Review:  Two pretty embarrassing episodes in a row.  I like this one better than Samaritan Snare because the plot isn’t as stupid and it’s occasionally funny, but it’s yet another statement episode (in this case, pro-choice).  Riker, who has matured since season one, slips yet again and decides the best course of diplomacy is nookie.  At least his prize this time is actually human.  Also, the Irish stereotyping goes just a wee too far.

One bright spot is (again) Pulaski, who is developing a strong bond with Worf that will unfortunately only get to last a few more episodes.

Have a good holiday weekend everyone.  I’m moving to my new house on Saturday, and hopefully will have new posts starting Monday.